Skip to main content

Duty on articles of jewellery @ 1%: Need for Clarification & Protection

The Government of India, vide Circular No. 1025/13/2016-CX  dated 22nd April, 2016,  has constituted the sub-committee of the High Level Committee to consider the issues related to compliance procedure for the excise duty, including records to be maintained, operating procedures and any other issues that may be relevant concerning the imposition of excise duty on Articles of Jewellery w.e.f 1st March 2016.

All associations have been given an opportunity to submit representation before the subcommittee in writing and the all India associations to state their case in person.
The response can be sent via e-mail to highlevelcommittee@gmail.com or by post addressed to the Office of the High Level Committee (HLC), Suite No. 215, The Janpath Hotel, Janpath Road, Opp. BSNL Building, New Delhi-110 001
Some of the points which I have come across which need clarification or protection are as under:
1) In order to be eligible to the concessional rate of duty of 1%, the articles of jewellery shall be manufactured from inputs or capital goods on which appropriate duty of excise leviable has been paid. Appropriate duty includes nil duty also. On failing to prove it, the duty at tariff rate i.e. 12.5% shall apply.
a) How to prove the duty paid character of the inputs used in the manufacture of articles of jewellery ?
b) On whom does the primary onus to prove the duty paid character of inputs lie ?
There are certain judicial decisions which suggest a way out for this situation.
in the case of Calcutta Paper Mills Manufacturing Company v. CEGAT and Ors. reported in 1986 (25) E.L.T. 939. The ld. Judge held:
“It is not possible for the petitioners to discharge onus that the base paper purchased by petitioners from the market is duty paid. The goods available in the market must be presumed to have been duty paid. It is absolutely impossible for a purchaser to know whether excise duty on the manufactured goods sold to the purchasers had already been paid by the manufacturers. If the purchaser has to satisfy the excise authorities that goods which he has purchased from the market suffers duty, it would impose a burden which no purchaser would be able to discharge. In the case of Sulekh Ram and Sons v. UOI and Ors. reported in 1978 (2) E.L.T. 525,1978 Delhi High Court has held that under excise system no goods can be removed from the place of manufacture without first paying the excise duty. Therefore, a purchaser can presume that the goods are duty paid. It would be incredible if the purchasers were required to ascertain whether Excise duty has already been paid by the manufacturer before the sale of such goods or not inasmuch as the purchasers have no means of knowing it.”
2) Under Rule 11CER 2002 goods can’t  be removed except on invoice which shall be serially numbered and shall contain the registration number, address of the concerned Central Excise division, name of the consignee, description, classification, time and date of removal, mode of transport and vehicle registration number, rate of duty, quantity and value, of goods and the duty payable thereon.
a) What will happen when a salesman of a jeweller carry items of jewellery on approval and sale basis. He travels to different areas of the city and also to other cities of the same state and cities of other states?
b) How will the excise accounting be done when part of the abovestated consignment is sold and part of it is return to the shop or factory?
3) Job work in article of jewellery.-
a) Under Rule 12AA (1) of CER 2002 it is provided that every person who gets articles of jewellery or other articles of precious metals on his behalf, on job work basis (called the said person) shall obtain registration, maintain accounts, pay duty leviable on such goods and comply with all the relevant provisions of these rules, as if he is an assessee.
b) Sub rule (7)provides that “Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, the job worker shall not be required to get himself registered or shall not be required to maintain any record evidencing the processes undertaken for the sole purposes of undertaking job work under these rules unless he has exercised his option in terms of the proviso to sub-rule (1).”
c) The proviso to sub-rule (1) was as under:-
“Provided that the job worker may, at his option, agree to obtain registration, maintain accounts, pay the duty leviable on such goods, prepare the invoice and comply with the other provisions of these rules and in such a case the provisions of these rules shall not apply to the said person.”
This proviso has since been omitted vide notification no. 8/2012 CE(NT) dated 17-3-2012.
Therefore the words “unless he has exercised his option in terms of the proviso to sub-rule (1)” in sub rule 7 need also to be omitted lest it may give an impression that a Job worker can undertake the responsibilities of the principal manufacturer.
4) Rule 22. Access to a registered premises.-           
a) It is provided that an officer empowered by the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, shall have access to any premises registered under these rules for the purpose of carrying out any scrutiny, verification and checks as may be necessary to safeguard the interest of revenue.
b) The said officer can also demand a list in duplicate of all the records prepared and maintained for accounting of transaction in regard to receipt, purchase, manufacture, storage, sales or delivery of the goods including inputs and capital goods, as the case may be;  all the financial records and statements including trial balance or its equivalent, cost audit reports  and the Tax Audit Report u/s 44 AB of the Income tax Act
The  above provisions are prone to misuse and can be used as an effective tool in the hands of excise inspectors to harass small jewellers and can also be a breathing ground for corruption. Suitable guidelines must be issued to prevent its misuse.
Rule 23 and 24:- Power to stop and search and detain or seize goods:- 
a) It is provided in Rule 23 that any Central Excise Officer, may search any conveyance carrying excisable goods in respect of which he has reason to believe that the goods are being carried with the intention of evading duty.
b) It is further provided in Rule 24 that if a Central Excise Officer,  has reason to believe that any goods, which are  liable to excise duty but no duty has been paid thereon or the said goods were removed with the intention of evading the duty payable thereon, the Central Excise Officer may detain or seize such goods.
The  above provisions are also prone to misuse particularly in case of small jewellers who carry the jewellery on their person and sell them on approval and sale basis. They don’t operate from any shop but from a carry bag and  travel to different areas of the city and also to other cities of the same state and cities of other  states.
What documents should they carry to prove that the goods are duty paid or that they are not the manufacturer but a retail trader who buys jewellery from the open market and sale them in the open market ?. They are engaged in only trading of the articles of jewellery.
Readers are encouraged to submit their own observations which need further clarification and support.
(Author can be reached on sonuandfirm@gmail.com )

Popular posts from this blog

Youtube Creative Commons (CC) क्या होते हैं और इनका इस्तेमाल कैसे करें

क्रिएटिव कॉमन्स (Creative Commons (CC) | Youtube Creative Common Video Kya Hote Hain - Janiye Hindi Me | Creative Common Videos का इस्तेमाल कैसे करें Rohit Maan Posted by Rohit Maan 10/04/2020 Creative Commons On youtube in hindi guide guruji दोस्तों सामान्यतः यूट्यूब पर जो सामग्री होती है, उसका इस्तेमाल कोई भी दूसरा व्यक्ति फिर से नहीं कर सकता है ओर ऐसा करना यूट्यूब की पॉलिसी के खिलाफ होता है और अगर आप यूट्यूब की किसी भी सामग्री को कॉपी करके फिर से यूट्यूब पर डालते हैं तो उसका ओरिजिनल मालिक आपके खिलाफ कॉपीराइट स्ट्राइक लगा सकता है और इसके चलते Youtube आपके चैनल को ब्लॉक कर सकता है। लेकिन यूट्यूब पर कुछ ऐसी सामग्री भी उपलब्ध हैं, जिनको आप इस्तेमाल कर सकते हैं और आपके खिलाफ कोई भी कॉपीराइट क्लेम नहीं आएगा। youtube की ऐसी सामग्री को Creative Commons सामग्री कहते हैं। जी हाँ दोस्तों, यूट्यूब पर उपलब्ध Creative Common वीडियो या सामग्री को आप डाउनलोड करके फिर से अपने चैनल पर कैसे भी इस्तेमाल कर सकते हैं और आपके खिलाफ ऐसा करने से कोई भी कॉपीराइट स्ट्राइक भी नहीं आएगा। Youtube पर उपलब्ध Creat...

Details overview of Busy Software

Download the latest versions of Busy Desktop, Busy Mobile App, Busy Agent, Busy BNS, Migration of Data from Tally to Busy, Formats for GST Data Upload, Sample Data and other related resources to help you get started with and usage of Busy Accounting Software. BUSY 21 Release 10.0 (Latest Release) of Busy Accounting Software – India’s No.1 GST Accounting Software file_download Download Busy 21 Release Notes Statutory Updates Archives BUSY 21 (Rel 9.7) file_download BUSY 21 (Rel 9.6) file_download BUSY 21 (Rel 9.5) file_download BUSY 21 (Rel 9.4) file_download BUSY Online Client Latest Release – Most Secure Online Accounting On Cloud file_download Download Busy Online Client BUSY Mobile App Download the latest version of BUSY Mobile App, which gives Busy Desktop Software Customers access to 100+ reports related to Sales, Purchases, Receivables, Payables, Stock and much more. The app also allows you to create and share receipts, invoices, orders and quotations with ease   BUSY BNS Dow...

9 Smart Ways To Boost Reader Engagement On Your Blog

Are you struggling to get your readers to engage with your blog? When I started blogging, I struggled too. But then I found that people who have an engaged audience on their blogs have this one thing in common: Their content is interesting. “How can I make my content interesting?” Well, that’s what I will be answering in this guide. I know how it feels when your readers read all your posts but don’t take the time to comment or share. I know it hurts. Reader engagement is the key to building a massive community of fans. Your readers engage with your blog in a lot of different ways. This engagement could take place in any of the following forms: Commenting on your blog posts Sharing your blog posts Navigating to another blog post Subscribing to your newsletters Or simply taking some action Reader engagement is also a search engine ranking factor. Google uses the bounce rate of your website to measure Reader Engagement. Bounce Rate is simply ...